ContactsDirect vs Clearly for monthly contact lens reorders in 2026

Affiliate disclosure: LensVerdict is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this page we may earn a commission via Commission Junction (CJ), at no extra cost to you. Commissions never change our rankings, which are based on price, selection, returns, and shopper fit. The CJ deep links below are pending program approval, so treat them as "where to compare" rather than live deals.

Not medical advice. LensVerdict is not an eye-care provider, and nothing here is medical or optometric advice. A contact-lens prescription must be set and verified by a licensed eye doctor, and your brand, power, and fit should be confirmed by that professional before you reorder anything.

If you already wear monthly contact lenses and just want to refill the same brand for less, the choice usually narrows to two of the best-known online sellers: ContactsDirect and Clearly. Both let you reorder a known prescription, both run frequent promo codes, and both ship an annual supply to your door. But they are built for different shoppers, and the gap shows up in two places that actually move money for a reorder: where they ship, and how they handle vision insurance.

This is a research-based comparison. We did not place orders or run a lab test. Everything below is drawn from each retailer's published policies, typical advertised pricing, and recurring themes reported by users in public reviews. Contact-lens prices move constantly with rebates and coupon stacking, so treat every dollar figure here as an illustrative example, not a live quote.

The 30-second verdict

• Best for U.S. shoppers using vision insurance: ContactsDirect. It is a U.S.-facing retailer (part of the EssilorLuxottica family) that advertises in-network vision-benefit handling, which can erase a meaningful chunk of an annual bill before any coupon.
• Best for Canadian shoppers and house-brand bargain hunters: Clearly, a Canada-first retailer (clearly.ca). In Canada it is the natural reorder home; in the U.S., confirm it actually ships to your address before you fall for a price.
• Best when you have no insurance and only care about sticker: Price your exact brand on both, factor in mail-in rebates, then let the True Annual Cost Calculator rank them on what you would pay for a 12-month supply.

How we evaluate (and what we did not do)

We compared the two retailers on the things that matter for a refill, where the lens choice is already made: per-box price behavior, realistic annual-supply cost, the auto-reorder experience, return and reship policies, and how each handles a contact-lens prescription and vision insurance. We leaned on published return windows, advertised promotions, and patterns in user reviews rather than a one-time hands-on order, because a single purchase on a single day tells you little about a category where the total swings with the coupon of the week. Last updated 2026.

ContactsDirect vs Clearly at a glance

The table below summarizes how the two retailers stack up on the dimensions a repeat buyer cares about. Figures are typical/estimated based on published pricing and policies; your brand, region, and prescription may differ.

Check current options: ContactsDirect · Clearly

Before you compare prices, settle the one variable that decides most of this: your location and whether you have a U.S. vision plan. If you are in the U.S. with VSP, EyeMed, or a similar benefit, ContactsDirect's insurance handling can beat a slightly lower Clearly sticker once the allowance lands. If you are in Canada, Clearly is the home-team option.

Per-box price: why the "cheaper" site flips

For a name-brand monthly lens (the silicone-hydrogel families most monthly wearers are prescribed), both retailers price per box and lean hard on promotions. In published pricing and user reports, neither is reliably the cheapest on every brand at every moment. ContactsDirect frequently advertises percentage-off coupons plus manufacturer mail-in rebates on annual supplies. Clearly is known for aggressive sitewide promo codes and for promoting its own house-brand lenses, which can undercut name brands when an eye doctor confirms an equivalent is appropriate for you.

The practical takeaway for a reorder: price your exact brand and box count on both sites on the same day, and factor in rebates. A name-brand rebate can quietly knock $50 to $150 off an annual order, but only if you actually submit it.

Annual-supply cost: the number that actually matters

Monthly lenses are sold by the box, but you live with the yearly total. A typical everyday wearer needs roughly 12 lenses per eye per year, so an annual supply is commonly two boxes per eye, give or take what your doctor specifies. That is where a per-box discount either compounds or barely registers.

Here is an illustrative example, using round numbers to show the mechanics, not any live price:

• If a six-pack of your monthly lens runs about $40 per box, an annual supply of four boxes is roughly $160 before any discount.
• A 20% promo brings that to about $128.
• A $60 manufacturer rebate on the annual order brings the net to roughly $68 for the year.

Run that math on both retailers with your brand and the winner is usually decided by which one currently stacks the better coupon-plus-rebate combination, not by the shelf price. In the U.S. with vision insurance, ContactsDirect's allowance can sit on top of all of that. That is exactly the calculation LensVerdict's True Annual Cost Calculator automates, so you compare yearly totals instead of stickers.

Auto-reorder and subscriptions

Both retailers support recurring shipments so you do not run out mid-year. ContactsDirect offers scheduled auto-reorder tied to the prescription on your account, and Clearly offers an auto-refill subscription. For a "set it and forget it" wearer this is roughly a wash, with two cautions that recur with online lens sellers in general:

1. Subscription prices can drift. A discount that applied to your first order may not carry to every recurring shipment, so re-check the per-box price a couple of times a year.
2. Prescription expiry pauses orders. When your Rx lapses, a reputable seller should stop the auto-shipment until you provide a current, doctor-verified prescription. That is a feature, not a bug, but plan the eye exam ahead so your supply does not stall.

Returns, reships, and prescription verification

For a reorder, the return policy mostly matters when a box arrives damaged or you order the wrong power. Both retailers publish return windows for unopened, undamaged boxes, and both verify your contact-lens prescription, which is a legal requirement, not a sales hurdle. ContactsDirect requires a doctor-verified prescription before fulfilling, consistent with U.S. rules; Clearly likewise requires a valid prescription. The honest guidance: keep a photo of your current prescription handy, and check the power, base curve, and diameter against your last box before you submit. Do that and you will rarely need the return policy at all.

Which should you pick?

• U.S. with vision insurance: Start with ContactsDirect and apply your benefit; the allowance often wins even when the sticker is a touch higher.
• In Canada: Clearly is the natural reorder home, especially if you are open to a doctor-approved house-brand equivalent.
• U.S. with no insurance: Price your exact brand on both, factor rebates, confirm Clearly ships to your address, then let the calculator rank the true annual totals before you commit.

Get your real number with the True Annual Cost Calculator

Most people overpay for monthly lenses because they compare per-box stickers instead of what a year actually costs them after box count, promos, rebates, shipping, and any insurance allowance. LensVerdict's True Annual Cost Calculator takes your lens type, wear pattern, and insurance situation, estimates your 12-month spend at each in-niche retailer, and ranks them by what you would pay. It is an illustrative estimate using typical published prices, not a quote or a medical recommendation, but it turns this comparison into one personalized dollar figure. Then send your winner straight to checkout: ContactsDirect or Clearly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is ContactsDirect or Clearly cheaper for monthly contacts?

Neither is reliably cheaper on every brand. In published pricing, both lean on promo codes; ContactsDirect adds manufacturer mail-in rebates on annual orders, while Clearly pushes sitewide deals and house-brand lenses. The real winner depends on your exact brand, the current coupon, whether you submit available rebates, and (in the U.S.) whether you apply vision insurance. Price both on the same day for your prescription and compare the annual total, not the per-box sticker.

Can I use vision insurance to reorder contacts online?

In the United States, ContactsDirect advertises in-network vision-benefit handling, which can apply your plan's contact-lens allowance toward the order. Clearly is a Canada-first retailer and is not built around U.S. vision plans. Coverage, allowances, and copays vary by plan, so confirm your specific benefit before ordering. This is general shopping information, not insurance or medical advice.

Does Clearly ship to the United States?

Clearly operates primarily as a Canadian retailer (clearly.ca). If you are in the U.S., do not assume U.S. delivery or U.S.-style insurance handling. Confirm shipping availability to your address on the retailer's own site before you compare prices, otherwise a great-looking Clearly price may not be one you can actually order.

Do I need a prescription to reorder the same monthly lenses?

Yes. Contact lenses are regulated, and a reputable retailer will require a valid, doctor-verified contact-lens prescription before shipping, even for a reorder of lenses you already wear. Your prescription, brand, and fit must be set by a licensed eye doctor. If your prescription has expired, you will need a current exam before either retailer can fulfill the order.

How many boxes is a one-year supply of monthly contacts?

For an everyday wearer, a year is commonly two boxes per eye (about 12 lenses per eye), so roughly four boxes of a standard six-pack, though your doctor may specify a different quantity based on your wear pattern. Buying the full annual supply at once is usually how you unlock the best per-box pricing and any manufacturer rebate, so compare the all-in yearly cost rather than ordering box by box.